Teddington Direct River Abstraction Statutory Consultation August 2025
Response from Richmond and Twickenham Friends of the Earth
Introduction
This response is from Richmond and Twickenham Friends of the Earth, a local group affiliated to Friends of the Earth England Wales and Northern Ireland working to protect and enhance the environment in the London Borough of Richmond upon Thames. We submitted responses to your previous consultations in March and December 2024.
We remain opposed to the Teddington DRA scheme although we are pleased that Thames Water has reduced the number of shafts and thus the impact on local greenspaces such as Moormead in Twickenham. Our concerns include the fact that the justification for this scheme as opposed to other solutions to future water shortages in London seems very flimsy, the impact of construction on Ham Lands, including the Ham playing fields and Burnell Avenue, and the effect of the chemicals and other polluting substances that will be in the treated effluent on the river ecology and human health.
Need for the scheme
We understand the need for more water for London and to avoid further stressing chalk streams. However, we have not seen a proper analysis of why the Teddington DRA represents “Best Value” compared to the many other options and do not feel we have ever been properly consulted on this. The only other option seriously being considered seems to be a reservoir in Oxfordshire that Thames Water has been trying and failing to build since the 1990s.
In the absence of proper costed alternatives for consultation we can only repeat that we do not think the Teddington DRA scheme is a good use of nearly a billion pounds. It seems only to provide a small amount of water relative to the amount that could be saved by mending more leaks, reducing demand by compulsory metering, rainwater harvesting and public education, and reviving existing infrastructure such as the Beckton desalination plant which has already been built but is rarely used and could have a much greater all year round capacity. It is difficult to believe that Thames Water is planning for the long term. We understood from staff at a public information event in July that the Teddington DRA had been chosen because it is the cheapest short term fix and there did not seem to have been much consideration of all the negatives of the scheme including value for money and impact on the environment.
Impact on water quality
We do not think that Thames Water should be allowed to discharge any treated sewage into the Thames at Teddington Lock, a location where many adults and children swim, row, sail and paddleboard, and which the Mayor of London has considered designating as a swimmable river. The treated sewage will still contain many undesirable chemicals such as PFAS (the level in the river is already far too high), pharmaceuticals and pesticides, plus EColi and cryptosporidium. These will have an impact on the river ecology and on human health which has not been properly assessed in the proposals and which we have no confidence will be properly monitored going forward. We also gather that the discharged treated sewage will not meet the standards of the revised EU Urban Wastewater Treatment Directive (2024/3019) which the UK should surely be striving to keep up with when planning projects of this nature. We are also concerned about the effect of the raised temperature of the effluent.
Mogden
We are concerned that building of the tertiary treatment works at Mogden will be an additional burden on a site that is already completely unable to cope with the demands upon it, frequently discharging untreated sewage into the Thames at Isleworth. Surely the whole site needs improving before deciding to add an additional treatment works? Given the terrible state of Thames Water’s finances, and the struggles of the existing ageing Mogden workforce presented for the whole nation to see on television recently, it is very hard for the public to have any confidence in Mogden being able to keep discharges to the river at Teddington to those that have been through tertiary treatment.
Disruption and damage during construction
It appears that there will be enormous disruption at Ham Playing Fields and Burnell Avenue whilst the pipeline is being built including a large amount of lorry movements. Both these locations are situated well off main roads down residential streets in green spaces that are extremely well used by the public and it appears that there will be a great deal of noise, congestion and vibration. There will be considerable upset and inconvenience at these sites being out of action for 1.5 – 2.5 years. The diversion of the towpath presumably for 2.5 years whilst the Burnell Avenue site is being worked on, will also affect thousands of people per day.
Ham Lands is a very important area for local biodiversity and wildlife but there doesn’t appear to have been much independent assessment of the possible impact on it or advice taken from local experts who have extensive knowledge of the flora and fauna, including bats, birds, insects and rare plant species.
We do not think that Thames Water should be boarding over green areas north of Riverside Drive and cutting down trees just to provide parking (consultation brochure page 34).
Some statements in the statutory consultation brochure (June 2025) are quite bizarre e.g. after acknowledging the significant effects on the community of construction it continues “There would be a significant positive effect on the region once the project is operational due to the increase in drought resilience, which would support the economy and facilitate housing growth”(page 51). Surely this is referring to the Lee Valley area not the Teddington and Ham area?!
Design of abstraction point and sewage input point
The design of the abstraction point is very intrusive in an area that is currently almost completely natural. The outfall into the river with surrounding buoys and ropes at a point where swimmers and boaters are used to going into the river is also not attractive.
Richmond and Twickenham Friends of the Earth
August 2025
richtwickfoe@gmail.com
