Heathrow Expansion National Policy Statement consultation August 2026

Draft Heathrow Expansion National Policy Statement: consultation on proposed amendments Published 18 June 2026 – closing date: 11:59pm on 1 September 2026.

henpsconsultation@dft.gov.uk

Full list of consultation questions

These questions are listed here to give you an overview of what we are asking. See the how to respond section for an online response form and other ways to respond. When considering responses to this consultation, the government will give greater weight to responses that are based on argument and evidence, rather than simple expressions of support or opposition, and those that provide reference to the specific sections of the draft HENPS to which their comments relate.

What is your name? Joanna Waddy

What is your email address? richtwickfoe@gmail.com

Are you responding on behalf of an organisation?  Yes

If yes: What is the name of your organisation?  Richmond and Twickenham Friends of the Earth

How many people does your organisation’s response represent?  Approximately 365

To what extent do you agree or disagree with the assessment of the need for the proposed expansion of Heathrow Airport? Explain your answer.

Strongly disagree

A third runway at Heathrow will add around 6 million tonnes of CO2 per year at a time when we are in the middle of a climate emergency. The extreme heat we are currently experiencing affects transport, crops, water consumption and energy demand. It puts vulnerable people at risk of heat stroke and death and reduces productivity. According to research by Manchester Metropolitan University[1], 55% of London homes are at risk of future overheating and a 1°C increase in summer temperatures reduces UK economic growth by about 2.4%, taking billions of pounds off the economy.

Building a third runway and demolishing over 750 homes will result in whole communities being torn apart – people who have grown up and raised their families there are now facing the prospect of their homes being bulldozed and thousands of other homes will be blighted by having the new runway on their doorstep.

In the Appraisal of Sustainability, major adverse impacts are identified with both schemes across almost every category – climate change, noise, air quality, health, biodiversity, water, soil etc.  Why on earth would anyone back a project with such horrifying impacts? Plans to divert rivers could also increase flood risk by altering drainage patterns. There may be issues with water resources as this is an area where a large data centre has just been approved at Manor Farm, Poyle as well as another at Hounslow. Data centres require huge amounts of electricity and water which can affect local infrastructure.

According to the DfT, the GDP impact has been massively reduced from the 0.5% of national GDP to a paltry 0.03% – 0.05%. Much of Chancellor Rachel Reeves’ economic benefit figures came from a Frontier Economics report commissioned and paid for by Heathrow itself containing figures that the DfT seems unable to verify. Frontier estimated a Net Present Value (sum of benefits less costs) of £25bn yet the DfT in its Heathrow Appraisal document forecast a NPV of between minus £35.5bn to minus £34.5bn![2]  A peer review of Frontier Economics’ report noted that 88% of the claimed GDP benefit was expenditure on construction. Indeed, the HENPS itself shows a lack of need for expansion in the London airport system before 2050.

Only 18% of Heathrow’s passengers were travelling for business purposes in 2024 and there has been a steady decline from 30% in 2014. In 2025, Heathrow was given the title of the world’s most connected airport for the third year running and despite claims to have been full for 20 years, the seat occupancy rate of 80% in 2025 showed that planes are far from full.

The economic wisdom of encouraging more outbound tourism is very questionable given that the ONS 2024 report shows that UK residents spent around £78.6 billion abroad in 2024 whilst overseas visitors only spent £32.5bn here. Not all those UK passengers left from Heathrow, but many would have done. This has a detrimental effect on the UK tourist industry.

Given that Heathrow had debts of around £17.6 billion in 2025, any expansion would have to be paid for by borrowing and airlines expect that to mean higher charges. The airport’s gearing ratio for June 2026 was 83% which is not much better than Thames Water’s precarious position.

The hub model is outdated as most passengers prefer to fly point to point and just over a quarter [3] of the additional travellers with a third runway could be transfer passengers, adding no benefit to the UK economy. There are already 6 airports serving the London airport system with over a million ATMs in 2024 transporting 178 million passengers. But now expansion plans are in place at Luton, City and Stansted to cram in another 50 million passengers or so and Gatwick expansion has also been approved – potentially adding another 40m passengers. There is absolutely no need for further expansion and another 65m more passenger journeys at Heathrow – it’s madness.

The government has proposed four tests which must be met for expansion to proceed. To what extent do you agree or disagree with how the government has set each of the ‘four tests’?

Explain your answer for each test:

AIR QUALITY (expansion must not cause new breaches of legal air quality limits taking account of appropriate mitigation)

Disagree

Whilst we may agree with the headline of the test – we suspect that mitigation will be used to enable harmful changes. Monitored air quality around Heathrow has improved in the last decade or so but there remains the very considerable impact of construction, road traffic and the operation of a further 276,000 flights in an area which has had poor air quality in the past. The Mayor of London expressed concern that the government is relying on outdated evidence from 2015 and that the cleaner air achieved by ULEZ will be wiped out by an expanded airport.

Aircraft operations emit ultrafine particles (UFPs), defined as particles with a diameter of less than 100 nanometres, which can penetrate the lungs, enter the bloodstream, and potentially reach organs such as the brain, heart, and placenta. A 2017 study by Maisol et al noted that UFP concentrations at 1.2km from Heathrow were around 10 times higher than elsewhere in London. According to this 2024 research from T&E[4], ‘People living in a 5km radius from an airport breathe in air that contains, on average, anything from 3,000 to 10,000 ultrafine particles per cm3 emitted by aircraft.’ These UFPs are linked to cardiovascular disease, dementia and respiratory problems. The World Health Organization has given guidelines for low concentrations as less than 1000 particles / cm3 (24-hour mean) and high as 10,000 particles / cm3 (24-hour mean).

When discussing Heathrow expansion in December, the London Assembly Environmental Committee recommended that: ‘The government should ensure that the role of UFPs from aircraft is properly assessed and included as part of the government’s tests for its ANPS, and ensure that there is a systematic process for measuring around Heathrow and other London airports.’ According to the Aviation Environment Federation ‘UFPs continue to be largely overlooked within the planning system due to a lack of legal limits.[5]

 

NOISE

(impacts must be limited so that noise is no worse than current levels (2024 baseline), with reductions where possible, supported by effective mitigation)

Disagree

Across the UK, more people are affected by noise from Heathrow with 359,700 households suffering daytime aviation noise at a level of 51 dB LAeq,16h or more and 305,400 households enduring nighttime aviation noise at a level of 45 dB LAeq,8h or more in 2024. These noise levels are higher than the levels recommended by the WHO and are above levels of the recent ANAS study which established that the point at which 10% of the population are highly annoyed had dropped from 54dB in the 2014 SoNA study to 43dB LAeq16hr. In the ANNE study on night noise, 10% are highly annoyed at 43dB and 20% highly annoyed at 46dB LAeq16hr.  The 43dB threshold meant that an expanded airport in 2055 would affect 3,405,000 people – 845,000 more than if no expansion. [6]  This confirms the view that campaigners have held for years that the SoNA study was flawed and the baseline was incorrect. Noise was not at an acceptable level in 2024 – based on the 43dB LAeq,16hr contour, 4,650,000 were within the estimated 840km² contour. The other issue is that noise contours conceal the harmful impacts of concentrated flight paths (Performance Based Navigation) and there has not been any proper investigation of the health impacts of those living under these concentrated PBN flight paths despite evidence from other countries – notably the USA.

 

Both the HAL and Heathrow West/Arora proposals are expected to result in ‘major adverse effects from noise’ according to the Appraisal of Sustainability. The Health Impact Analysis (at 4.11.4) notes that ‘the risk of hypertension, coronary heart disease and stroke may increase by approximately 7-17% per 10dB increase exposure with studies around Heathrow Airport identifying elevated risks among more exposed populations.’ It goes on to say: ‘Higher levels of exposure in some locations could lead to increased annoyance, sleep disturbance, impacts on educational attainment, and other associated health effects.’ The Planning Inspectorate’s Scoping Opinion on the Proposed Expansion of Heathrow (dated 10 Oct 2025 page 614) recommended that the Environmental Statement must adopt WHO Environmental Noise Guidelines (2018) and assess health impacts using both average and event-based metrics. For aviation noise, the WHO guidelines recommend limits of 45 dB Lden and 40 dB Lnight to avoid adverse health impacts.

The shorter 2400m runway of the Heathrow West scheme means that the heavy, noisy A380s and 777s would not be able to take off on this runway, resulting in more noise on the southern runway as many of these long-haul planes run late into the evening to the Middle East and South America.

There are so many pending factors such as proposed changes to Air Navigation Guidance and the proposal that noise may only be prioritised to 5000ft, Easterly Alternation, airspace modernisation, respite routes and Westerly Preference that the noise could be significantly worse for those under flightpaths and respite may be reduced or not particularly meaningful because of multiple flightpaths. The most effective mitigation against the noise of quarter of a million extra flights each year is not to build a third runway.

 

CLIMATE CHANGE MITIGATION (the scheme must be compatible with the UK’s legally binding climate targets, including carbon budgets and net zero)

Disagree

The DfT has identified that increased capacity will result in ‘significant adverse effects’. The 6 tonnes of carbon per year from an expanded Heathrow would result in aviation emissions being twice as high in 2050 as the CCC recommended.

A report by AECOM (commissioned by the DfT ) has stated that Sustainable Aviation Fuel (SAF) and engineered removals will ‘not remove the increase in absolute emissions associated with the higher level of aviation activity’.  The Transport and Environment Group (T&E) believe that technological developments will not meet the pathways unless demand and capacity is managed.

The CCC has recently warned that there are significant risks in the delivery of SAF needed to contribute to the government’s pathway in 2027.  According to a recent press release by Celeste Hicks of the AEF, Jet Zero’s projection of 19MT residual emissions by 2050 using SAF and greenhouse gas removals is now forecast to be 28MT. These would need to be removed and stored away permanently. Professor Kevin Anderson of Manchester University warns against relying on oil and gas industries ‘selling snake oil again’ as carbon capture and storage barely exists – despite being around for thirty years, only 0.03% of fossil fuel emissions have been captured.

The draft HENPS refers to the 2026 aviation forecasts publication showing the trajectory of aviation emissions to 2050 and the impact of decarbonisation policies. This analysis includes updated evidence on the uptake of SAF and efficiency gains, which has resulted in more residual emissions in 2050 and a greater reliance on greenhouse gas removals than in the 2022 Jet Zero Strategy. Additionally, the HENPS does not seem to take account of the non-CO2 emissions which are estimated to double the impact.

We have no confidence that this scheme would be compatible with climate targets.

Economic growth across the country

(expansion must deliver a credible and meaningful contribution to UK‑wide economic growth, supported by a clear plan for how benefits (for example, jobs, productivity and connectivity) will actually be realised)

Disagree

Heathrow has already reduced its passenger forecast to 83.6m for 2026 due to reduced travel demand and the Middle East conflict. At the time of the Airports Commission, it was decided that either Gatwick or Heathrow needed to expand to meet demand as London’s five airports made it the best-connected city in the world. But now Stansted, Gatwick, Luton and London City have all received planning consent to expand.

The Appraisal of Sustainability Report estimates that by 2055 between 50K and 61K jobs will be created in the local economy, but it also says this may just be redistribution of labour within the economy, rather than additional growth. There could also be a reduction in passenger numbers at other airports such as Manchester and Birmingham, resulting in job losses, and forecasts from the New Economics Foundation ‘suggest that in 2050 …there could be 15,200 jobs lost in the wider regions of the UK and displaced to London and the south-east’[7]

To what extent do you agree or disagree that the proposed mitigation measures for environmental impacts resulting from Heathrow expansion requirements are deliverable, effective and proportionate? Explain your answer.

Disagree

Aviation demand needs to be managed as we cannot continue to emit huge quantities of carbon that will be around for hundreds of years then rely on expensive and unproven technology to mitigate this. Despite Heathrow having set its target for SAF in 2026 to 5.6%, the availability and cost of SAF will restrict its use. Heathrow is currently incentivising airlines for half the cost difference (£650 per tonne) between SAF and kerosene. The other issue is reliance on unproven and expensive technology such as Direct Air Carbon Capture and Storage (DACCS) The CCC recommended that the Seventh Carbon Budget should be set at 535 MtCO2e for the period from 2038 to 2042. This should include the UK’s share of international aviation and shipping emissions, and the Government should plan to meet it through domestic action without resorting to international credits. The UK Emissions Trading Scheme (UK ETS) and the global offsetting scheme CORSIA simply shift the problem to other countries.

Because flight paths have not been determined, it’s impossible to know the levels of noise we will be subjected to but it’s unlikely that adding quarter of a million planes each year will alleviate the impact. Noise insulation will only be provided to the most severely affected leaving those who can afford it to pay thousands for acoustic triple glazing so that they can sleep.

Do you agree or disagree that the proposed ban on scheduled night flights for Heathrow following expansion should be defined based on the time a ‘plane takes off or lands’ instead of ‘departure from and arrival to terminal’? Explain your answer.

Agree

The time the plane actually departs is often the point at which large numbers are disturbed. There should ideally be 8 hours without planes in keeping with the LAeq 8hr metric but if only seven hours, based on take-off and landing times, that should be 11pm till 6am as recommended by the Planning Inspectorate scoping opinion (Page 613) dated 10 Oct 2025.

 

To what extent do you agree or disagree with the proposed designation of Heathrow expansion as defined in the draft HENPS as Critical National Growth Infrastructure (CNGI)? Explain your answer.

Strongly disagree

The Heathrow Expansion Appraisal Report notes that additional ATMs at Heathrow remain low until the later years due to additional capacity from other London airport expansions. It is farcical that expansion of this airport, a private company wholly owned by overseas investors, generating such a small long-term benefit to the economy should be designated as Critical National Growth Infrastructure. This just seems like a cynical ploy by Government to avoid legal challenge and force through a plan which wouldn’t stand up to public scrutiny.

To what extent do you agree or disagree that the compensation for affected residents is fair? Explain your answer.

Disagree

The people whose communities are being decimated have been living under the shadow of this for decades with a commensurate impact on their house values so even 125% will not buy them a similar property in the surrounding areas. It will be very difficult for those elderly people, who have spent most of their adult lives building relationships in their community, to start over and form new friendships and support networks.

To what extent do you agree or disagree with the requirements for surface access, including the passenger mode share targets, and the Surface access vision document?

Agree

Whilst we agree with the targets of passengers and staff using public transport and active travel, it has taken the introduction of the Elizabeth Line and perhaps incentives for staff to increase the public transport mode share to 46% after barely moving for a decade. However, the addition of another 14 million passengers (even if the 50% target were met) would overwhelm the existing public transport network even if there were improvements on the Western Rail link.  And who will pay for the rail links?

Please also provide any further comments you may have on surface access.

Heathrow may be relying on the fact that 80% of new cars and 70% of new vans need to be zero emission by 2030 but there has already been backsliding on this target from its introduction in 2020. According to the BBC, the Gov’t is looking at reducing the percentages to between 50 and 70%. Why are 30,000 parking spaces being planned? The addition of 22 million highway trips a year would massively increase air pollution, congestion and carbon emissions.

To what extent do you agree or disagree that the Making Best Use policy should be updated?

Agree

What, if anything, would you like to be considered in any update to the Making Best Use policy? Explain your answer.

It should apply to Heathrow – they may wish for a third runway but with a seat occupancy rate of 80% there’s still plenty of space on their planes. There should be no further airport expansion – all airports need to manage demand and make best use of their existing runways.  Most travellers prefer to leave from their local airport rather than a hub. This constant pursuit of growth will be very harmful for the economy and the environment in the long run.

To what extent do you agree or disagree that the draft HENPS provides an effective framework for decision making on development consent applications? Explain your answer.

We liked the non-technical summaries but there was still a great deal of reading to do. It was not initially clear why the Arora proposal was also selected to progress, given the HENPS was specifically based on Heathrow North West Runway. Almost all the technical reports are emphasising the negative impacts, so the HENPS lacks credibility especially on the economic argument.

Do you have any comments on any of the additional supporting documents, including the Appraisal of Sustainability (AoS), Habitats Regulations Assessment (HRA), Equality Impact Assessment (EqIA) and Health Impact Analysis (HIAn)?

We are concerned about the diversion of watercourses as well as the exposure of wildlife to noise, air and water pollution (especially with PFAs) during both construction and operation. It feels that the designation of CNGI will override any environmental concerns in order to force through this development.

The Health Impact Analysis describes the noise and air quality impacts as ‘moderate adverse (significant)’ [8], but the HENPS does not make clear whether that constitutes unacceptable interference with human health. The HENPS says the Secretary of State should consider what monitoring and enforcement is required but none of this is legally binding.

The Public Sector Equality Duty (PSED) requires public bodies to consider the needs of people in relation to characteristics protected by the Equality Act 2010. Development applications must demonstrate due consideration for the PSED and wider obligations under the Act. Do you agree that the draft HENPS takes due regard for its legal obligations under the PSED? Explain your answer.

Disagree

Aircraft noise can result in disturbed sleep which can impact children’s learning.  They also need at least 8 hours’ sleep – far more than the six and a half hours proposed. So, children, the elderly and those with disabilities who are house bound will suffer noise to a greater extent.

There are high levels of deprivation, housing shortages and poor health in some of the boroughs next to Heathrow and these are the people who will be most impacted by the noise and pollution of a third runway. The demolition of over 750 homes will add to the housing shortage and difficulties for people coming into the area for work. The proliferation of HMOs round the airport simply compounds the disadvantage.

 

What, if any, additional comments do you have on the draft HENPS?

If this is supposed to be a framework for expansion, it fails miserably: the supporting research does not show that mitigation will prevent real harm to either the people living round Heathrow or the environment.

[1] Why hotter summers are bad for the UK economy | Manchester Metropolitan University

[2] Heathrow Expansion Appraisal Report Page 46

[3] DfT Proportion of Transfer Passengers AVI0106 2024

[4] Ultrafine particles from planes put 52 million Europeans at… | T&E

[5] AEF UFPs briefing Feb26.docx

[6] Draft Heathrow Expansion National Policy Statement Appraisal of Sustainability (AoS) Noise Annex (page29)

[7] The economic impact of a third runway at Heathrow | New Economics Foundation

[8] Health Impact Analysis (HIAn) for the draft Heathrow Expansion National Policy Statement non-technical statement