Letter to LB Richmond councillors re Climate Emergency

Dear Cllr Neden-Watts, Cllr Juriansz and Cllr Warren

We are writing on behalf of Richmond and Twickenham Friends of the Earth and Extinction Rebellion Richmond.

We welcome the Council’s declaration of a climate emergency in 2019 and the resulting strategy and action plan.  We have also read with interest the recent paper “Supporting Domestic Retrofitting in the London Borough of Richmond upon Thames” to the PPRB.

Whilst we appreciate that some aspects of planning are subject to national regulations, we would like to see the Council acting with a greater sense of urgency to reduce the planning and other barriers to retrofitting in the Borough, especially in relation to the installation of heat pumps and solar panels.  With a few exceptions (e.g. dedicated environmentalists) most householders will consider installing a heat pump at the time when their current boiler needs replacing.  Faced with the choice of an expensive and long-drawn-out planning process or installation of a replacement boiler, most residents will choose the latter.  As our case study below shows, an attempt to ‘do the right thing’ can be stressful, expensive and difficult.

With a Borough-wide target to be net zero by 2043, and over 45% of emissions for the borough originating from domestic sources (including domestic electricity and gas usage), it is vital that the majority of homes in the Borough are retrofitted well before 2043.  Whilst it may be deemed desirable to keep the Borough’s ‘heritage’ housing looking nice and traditional, in reality climate change has the potential to cause significantly more public disbenefit than a heat pump on the wall, or a solar panel on the roof, of a house in a conservation area.  Under feasible climate scenarios a significant proportion of the Borough could be subject to severe flood risk, large numbers of the Borough’s trees could die and prized assets such as Richmond Park become increasingly at risk of severe fires.  This is the real legacy that we risk leaving to the next generation of Richmond residents – a far more damaging inheritance than alterations to historic houses which some might find less pleasing to the eye.  It is in this context that we believe the Council should be seeking to do everything within its power, as soon as possible, to encourage and facilitate the fitting of heat pumps and solar panels at scale within the Borough.

We would like to invite Cllr Neden-Watts and a member of the Task and Finish Group to one of our meetings this Autumn to discuss this in more detail and explore ways in which the Council might lead the way in fighting climate change and mitigating the worst of its potential impacts on the Borough and its residents.  We usually meet on the first Wednesday of each month in Twickenham at 7.30pm.  Would you be free to attend either our November (6th) or December (1st) meeting?  If these dates don’t suit then we can agree a mutually convenient alternative.

All the best

Joanna Waddy – On behalf of Richmond and Twickenham Friends of the Earth

Ann Twiselton – On behalf of Extinction Rebellion Richmond

Case Study

R&J live in a small house in a conservation area.  Despite being in their 80s, they wanted to ‘do the right thing for the planet’ and retrofit their house.  They have had internal wall and loft insulation; new energy efficient wooden sash windows; and replaced a glass roof with a well-insulated solid one.  In order to do this they had to remove their existing radiators to make room for the internal wall insulation.  They expected to be able to replace them fairly quickly with new radiators and an air source heat pump.  It has in fact taken them around 18 months (including a winter with no central heating).  In addition, it has cost them £206 in planning fees and £1308 for a compulsory environmental noise survey and impact assessment (including VAT), plus the cost of having to employ an architect to help them navigate the system.  All this is in addition to the cost of the pump itself, and a cylinder.

J describes the experience of the planners as overly bureaucratic, inaccessible and slow to respond.  It has caused them significant stress, and the cold exacerbated R’s existing respiratory health issues.  The pump is finally due to be installed next week.  Tragically R passed away just over a week ago and so never lived to see the benefits of the works that had caused him so much anxiety and worsened his health condition.